Hiring a Contractor Checklist

Ray Cogan

Hiring the right contractor is one of the most important decisions you’ll make during a home improvement or repair project, according to the Better Business Bureau. (Having the right homeowners insurance  can give you peace of mind, too.) Whether you’re looking for someone to do a small repair, or adding an addition to your home, it’s important to make sure you’ve hired someone you can trust to do the job. 

We’ve pulled together some tips to consider when you’re getting ready to hire for your next home improvement project.

FINDING A CONTRACTOR

  • What’s your project? Are you looking to remodel one room or make minor updates to a small space? The type of project determines whether you’ll need a general contractor or someone more specialized.
  • Check in with your local homebuilders’ association. You’ll be able to search contractors within your area and put together a list of potentials.
  • Get referrals . Ask your friends, family and coworkers who they’ve worked with in the past. They may have a great contractor you haven’t heard of — or know of a few you should stay away from.
  • Prepare ahead. Compile a list of reputable contractors  before  you need one. The stress of an emergency repair might impair your judgment.
  • Get multiple estimates. If price is a big concern, checking with only one contractor won’t guarantee you the best price. But the cheapest estimate also doesn’t ensure the best work. If you have the time, try and get a second or third quote.

VETTING A CONTRACTOR

  • Association check. See if the trade association(s) to which they belong stipulates a code of ethics, minimum hours of satisfactory work and trade exams.
  • Search for reviews (good or bad). Check in with your state attorney general’s office and the Better Business Bureau to see if there are any complaints against the contractor. Glance over their public company reviews on social networks or other trusted review sites.

Once you’ve selected a contractor, ask for proper documentation as you move closer to signing off on the job.

PAPERWORK TO SEE FROM YOUR CONTRACTOR

  • A copy of their contractor’s license. Licensing and certification requirements vary by state. Check with your local State Consumer Protection Office to view your area’s licensing laws to ensure your contractor is verified and up to date.
  • Certificate of insurance. Ask for both general liability, property damage and workers’ compensation coverage and make sure they are up to date.
  • A written warranty. You’ll want a warranty for the work they do, the materials they use and those who work for them.
  • A list of references . Have they done a project similar to what you are looking to have done?
  • A detailed quote. The quote should outline all material used and labor that is expected to be done.
  • The contract. Detailed within the contract should be the cost, work to be done, time schedules, guarantees, payment schedules, building permits and other expectations. (Keep this contract for future reference or if any questions arise after the job is complete).
  • A receipt. Make sure to get a receipt that is marked “paid in full” when a job is completed and you make the final payment.
  • Discuss the need for a lien waiver. This assures you that your general contractor is paying any subcontractors or suppliers they are working with, so you aren’t liable for additional costs down the road.

AS THE JOB COMES TO A CLOSE

  • Keep records. Find a place to keep all your paperwork, receipts and change orders. Consider making digital copies as well.
  • Snap a photo. Map your progress with weekly photos – or save them for a big before and after reveal.
  • Write a review. Good or bad, share details of the work they did, how well they stuck to the timeline and what the finished product looked like. This will help others in their search for hiring a contractor of their own.

Most contractors are trustworthy and are in this line of work for the right reasons. However, some scammers pose as contractors and don’t actually have your best interests in mind. Here are some signs that should make you think twice.

PROCEED WITH CAUTION IF...

  • The contractor asks you to pay the entire balance up-front.
  • The contractor only accepts cash.
  • The contractor avoids giving you a written contract.
  • A contractor goes door-to-door – or pops up right after a storm.
  • The contractor lists a P.O. Box instead of a street address.
  • The contractor uses a vehicle that doesn’t list the business name.
  • A contractor offers to pay your insurance deductible.
  • A contractor offers to arrange a loan for you.
  • You have little to no experience hiring home contractors.
  • You’re unable to access the areas of your home that a contractor claims are damaged. Ask a friend or family member or another trusted professional to inspect the area for you.
  • You’re not 100% clear about the contract wording. It’s OK to ask questions or have someone else review the contract with you.

Finally, let your  Erie Insurance agent  know when you’re planning a home improvement project and when it’s completed. If your project adds value to your home, you’ll also want to make sure your homeowners insurance policy is updated to reflect the right amount of coverage. Learn more about homeowners insurance from ERIE.

cars driving in snow Lindquist Insurance
By Ray Cogan December 8, 2025
Car insurance coverage for winter driving. Contact Lindquist Insurance today for a free policy review. Our experienced agents will help you understand your current coverage, identify any gaps, and provide recommendations tailored to your needs and budget. Serving Annapolis and Fredrick, MD.
rain hitting pavement Lindquist Insurance
By Ray Cogan November 24, 2025
At Lindquist Insurance, we specialize in helping businesses in the Annapolis and Frederick, MD regions safeguard their property and operations through customized commercial property insurance. Whether you face coastal storms, winter freezes, or routine business risks, we’ll work with you to build a commercial policy.
By Ray Cogan November 17, 2025
At Lindquist Insurance, we specialize in helping business owners in the Annapolis and Frederick, MD area secure the right general liability protection designed for their operations and industry. Call us today for a customized review and quote.
fireplace
October 10, 2025
Our insurance agent based in Frederick provides tips for fall protection. We can help you balance protection and affordability so you’re ready for anything the season brings.
scary home
By Ray Cogan October 10, 2025
We offer business insurance in Frederick. Learn how to avoid the most common business insurance mistakes. Contact us today to schedule your free business insurance review.
home during fall
By Ray Cogan September 22, 2025
Our insurance agent based in Frederick has provided a checklist to help you prepare for the season ahead. Contact us today and let us help you prepare.
leaves on wet road
By Ray Cogan September 11, 2025
We offer car insurance in Frederick. Learn about five common fall driving hazards and how car insurance helps keep you protected. Contact us today to review your policy.
credit report
By Ray Cogan August 21, 2025
Before you get an insurance quote, our Frederick insurance company explains the five things that will affect your quote and how you can lower it.
woman refinishing a chair
By Ray Cogan August 11, 2025
We offer business insurance in Frederick. Don’t wait for the next storm, lawsuit, or data breach to realize you’re not fully protected. Now is the time to review your insurance portfolio.
More Posts