Understanding Premium vs. Regular Gas

Ray Cogan
gas pump

Most people are clear on which type of gas their car needs. But not as many are clear on the differences between regular and premium gas.

Why use regular instead of premium gas?

One obvious difference is the price.

According to the U.S. Energy and Information Administration premium fuel nationally averages about 60 cents more per gallon than regular gasoline, and 25 cents more than midgrade gas.

What is the difference in octane levels?

Octane is how much compression a fuel can withstand before igniting, or rather it’s a measurement of a fuel’s ability to avoid knock.  Gas stations typically carry three octane grades. State laws regulate which octane levels can be listed as premium, midgrade or regular. Typically “regular” gas is 87 octane, “midgrade”  is 89 octane and over 91 octane is “premium” gasoline. Some states label top-tier gasoline with 93 octane as “ultra” gas.

Can I switch from premium to regular gas?

Cars are designed to run best with a specific type of fuel.

A higher octane gas won’t ignite as quickly, which explains why high-performance cars with high compression engines often require higher octane gas. Engines that take higher octane fuel tend to work more efficiently and emit less emissions and exhaust.

It is important to use the required octane for your specific car. Using the right octane level can prevent damage to your car’s engine and help it run at maximum efficiency.

If you use a lower than recommended level, the gas may combust too fast for your engine. That can cause the engine to make a knocking noise. In addition to this unwanted noise, a lower than recommended gas can also reduce your car’s power and fuel economy and cause engine damage.

When it comes to the opposite—using a fuel with a higher octane rating than recommended—the risk of danger is lower. The general consensus is that using premium gas when your car can run on regular gas doesn’t deliver any extra benefits when it comes to engine life, fuel economy or reduced emissions.

If your engine uses higher compression ratios, typically you will need to use higher octane-rated gas. Your owner’s manual will let you know what gas is best for your car model, or look inside your fuel door; it should have a sticker showing your car’s fuel requirements.

If your car requires premium fuel, the sticker will read “Premium Unleaded Fuel Only” as well as the octane level required; some models will simply note “Premium Fuel Recommended.”

Can you mix premium and regular gas?

Mixing different octanes doesn’t improve your car engine’s performance. It is best to stick with the manufacturer’s recommendation for peak performance. 

Does premium gas last longer?

If your car’s manual simply states to use “premium” or “premium recommended” you may want to test the different premium levels to see how your car’s performance changes. You can do this by getting your gas tank to the quarter level, or lower, and fill up with one of the premium grades. Keep a log to track of your gas mileage while driving with the different premium gas octanes. Test the different octane levels and pay attention to how your car feels and sounds while driving; also note any differences in acceleration rate.

To improve your car’s overall performance drive it more efficiently. For example, don’t floor the gas when taking off from a red light or stop sign. When driving distances, highway mileage, drive at a consistent fashion without making quick accelerations.

At Erie Insurance, we know life is all about balance. Whether you’re selecting the best gas or the right insurance for your car, it is important to find the sweet spot between your budget and getting the protection you need. With flexible options, ERIE Agents can help you customize your coverage at just the right price. Learn more about auto insurance  or  find a local ERIE agent  near you.

This was originally published in 2017. It was updated in 2019 with new information. Amanda Prischak and Sara Erhartic contributed to this story.

two men working in a plant Lindquist Insurance
By Ray Cogan January 21, 2026
Visit Lindquist Insurance to request a business insurance review or quote, and let our team help you pair the right general liability policy with smart risk management so your business can grow with confidence throughout 2026 and beyond.​ Contact us today. Serving Frederick, MD and Annapolis, MD.
Family in home Lindquist Insurance
By Ray Cogan January 13, 2026
Make this the year you actually check “review my homeowners insurance” off your list. Visit Lindquist Insurance to request a personalized homeowners’ policy review or quote, and let a live local agent help you update your coverage, uncover potential discounts, and an updated homeowners insurance plan.
two men shaking hands
By Ray Cogan December 15, 2025
Our insurance agency staff in Frederick can help you evaluate your insurance needs for 2026. Starting the new year with confidence in your coverage brings peace of mind.
cars driving in snow
By Ray Cogan December 8, 2025
We offer car insurance in Frederick. Winter driving increases accident rates during the holiday season. Be sure your car insurance coverage is adequate for winter driving.
rain hitting pavement
By Ray Cogan November 24, 2025
We offer commercial property insurance in Frederick to protect your business from seasonal risks. Call us today for a free review of your commercial property insurance needs.
people in a courtroom
By Ray Cogan November 17, 2025
We offer general liability insurance in Frederick to protect your business from costly claims. Call Lindquist Insurance today for a customized review and quote.
fireplace
October 10, 2025
Our insurance agent based in Frederick provides tips for fall protection. We can help you balance protection and affordability so you’re ready for anything the season brings.
scary home
By Ray Cogan October 10, 2025
We offer business insurance in Frederick. Learn how to avoid the most common business insurance mistakes. Contact us today to schedule your free business insurance review.
home during fall
By Ray Cogan September 22, 2025
Our insurance agent based in Frederick has provided a checklist to help you prepare for the season ahead. Contact us today and let us help you prepare.
More Posts